Editor's Choice

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Featured Post
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Let us build Pakistan" has moved.
30 November 2009

All archives and posts have been transferred to the new location, which is: http://criticalppp.com

We encourage you to visit our new site. Please don't leave your comments here because this site is obsolete. You may also like to update your RSS feeds or Google Friend Connect (Follow the Blog) to the new location. Thank you.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Showing posts with label Accountability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Accountability. Show all posts

Monday, 23 November 2009

Sindhis responsible for 97% of corruption in Pakistan: NRO's message



By Abdul Nishapuri

Once again, it would appear that the rules are different for peoples from Sindh whereas politicians, bureaucrats and military personnel from Punjab and elsewhere are angels who do not have a spot of corruption on their careers. Or at least, that is what the establishment wants us to believe through its "NRO" tool.

NRO list out, 34 politicians among 8,000 beneficiaries
By Amir Wasim

Sunday, 22 Nov, 2009 (Dawn)

ISLAMABAD: A majority of the NRO beneficiaries have been bureaucrats and government officials as a list, released by the government on Saturday, contained names of only 34 politicians out of a total of 8,000.

According to the list, almost 97 per cent of the beneficiaries are from Sindh. The ordinance will lapse on Nov 28 in the light of the Supreme Court’s July 31 verdict in the PCO judges case.

The list shows that a total of 8,041 people — 7,793 from Sindh — have benefited from the National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO), promulgated by former president Pervez Musharraf on Oct 5, 2007.

These people have got withdrawn 3,478 cases (3,320 in Sindh) registered against them on charges of corruption, financial bungling, misuse of authority and criminal charges.

What do ordinary Pakistanis think about NRO?
(various sources including pkpolitics, friendskorner etc)

Pakistan said:
7,793 from Sindh, this does not mean that sindhis are corrupt.
Ghulam Agmad Bloor from ANP said on a TV show that 99% corruptionwas done in Punjab through loans written off ,by a specific part in punjab, and they built from sugar to terxtile industry.
These corrupt military, civil bureaucrats and government officials should be brought to justice.

This was time when every MNA and MPA in punjab was running to get loan and get write off and then develop a factry.

Worh to see that time a loan beneficiary and calculate the amount with interest toay.
———————————–
http://www.dawn.com/wps/wcm/connect/dawn-content-library/dawn/news/pakistan/12-pms+wife+paid+rs455m+against+rs570m+liabilities–bi-07
———————————-

Wahid Doyum said:
How accurate are the cases against those on the list? NAB after all was run through Musharraf’s orders and the history of judiciary is well known.

waw said:
The above list is half of the looters. The list – which consists the gangsters from Sind- was prepared by the looters from Punjab when they (Nawaz and his team) were in government. Now the looters from Sind (Zardari and party) are in government and they are in process of preparing another list of gangsters who belong to Punjab. All these consist of one group- the looters of the nation. Now Nawaz Sharif is protecting them- Then Zardari will be protecting Nawaz. You can say two teams of looters – the lahori group and the larkana group- looting the country for the last 65 years.

agrana75 said:
This list is only for the “idiot” politicians who instead of buying judiciary and other related officials , preffered to get rid of the cases through NRO. There are many shrewd and clever politicians who foresaw long time ago that such ordinances had no long term validity and effect. They “managed” to get clear themselves through the judicary and NAB. Now, question is that no body investigating the “CRIME” even if some got acquittal from the courts, it looks some angels came down to earth and looted the money ands thats all.

i_shah said:
What about generals. they surely arent angles and have had major chunk of the national budget. I guess corruption is legal for them. afterall who needs to deal in cash when they get plots and agricultural land at dirt cheap prices:

http://www.satribune.com/archives/Aug17_23_02/P1_landgrabbing.htm#top

http://antisystemic.org/satribune/www.satribune.com/archives/200504/P1_ss3.htm

sabazbagh said:
Many of us MAY BE familiar with a fact that especially when an officer from the army reaches the rank of a ‘Brigadier’ he (& now a ’she’ also) is LITERALLY ‘OFFERED’ ON A SILVER PLATTER, a prized piece of land in any military cantonment & MAY BE, then or (sometimes earlier or later,) when he reaches the rank of a Major:/Lt:General, he is THEN AGAIN ‘OFFERED’ the best ‘PIECES’ of STUD FARMS/AGRICULTURAL LANDS; that he MAY HAVE NEVER DREAMED-OFF?

A major question is then normally asked by majority of lower rank officers, sitting within or outside GHQ that ‘WHY THEM & NOT US?

What is called a ‘rat-race’ is THUS INITIATED by senior military officers with the backing & greediness of their spouses.

Consequently, there is a lot of ‘heart-burning’ amongst the lower ranks, whether themselves officers, or other ranks (comprising of Jco’s, Nco’s & men.) Is there any JUSTIFICATION for such a dole-out or ‘charity, whatever you may call it?

In order to ‘lessen’ the so-called ‘heart-burning’ among junior officers of the rank of Lt:Colonels & Majors, it was THUS decided about 15/20 years back, to ‘DULY REWARD’ them too, by the ‘CHARITABLE ENDOWMENT’ organization called the GHQ.

This legacy of ‘buying-off’ the LOYALTIES of the officers-lot was left behind by our ‘clever & intelligent’ Britishers, who ‘devastated’ every facet of life, during their, over 200 years rule,) NOT AT THEIR OWN EXPENSE, BUT AT OURS!

Will ever any army officer voluntarily, (whether TODAY or TOMORROW,) return back to GHQ, the PRIZED land ( worth billions in Pak Rs) , house or a residential flat, ( worth millions?)
Your own answer, NOT SURPRISINGLY would be a big, NO !

murtazahasaan said:
The NRO list of Beneficiaries is not as big of an issue as the fight against terrorism. The media can help us unite to raise voice against terrorism. We are Pakistanis and we can do this.

sabazbagh said:
Whatever OTHER BENEFITS that a serving or a retired military officer obtains during his service with the civil govt, ( especially during past martial years of Ayub, Zia or any other, such era; they are usually ‘OVER & ABOVE’ what he gets from GHQ, either during his ‘pre’ or ‘post’ retirement period of service in the military.

I seriously think that the Ministry of Defense should also release a similar LIST, showing the names of beneficiaries of the three services, i.e; Pak Army Navy & Air Force, ‘who had their cake & ate it’ too & also ‘burned both ends of their candles’!

MAY BE, there will be so much of pressure by retired military officers upon the incumbent Service Chiefs,that such a list will NEVER see the light of the day.

MAYBE, (I AGAIN repeat MAYBE,) it could result in a ’swift, short & quick’ move by the military, to SAVE IT” s HOLY COWS , TOO, FROM PUBLIC EXPOSURE?

Adonis said:
Given the backdrop of all the propaganda and the virile hatred that many ignorant and gullible Pakistanis keep expressing about politicians, this list of NRO beneficiaries is an eye opener.

It is time for us to realize that our politicians are not the source of our problems, rather it is the corrupt civil and military bureaucracy.

Politicians are accountable to the people and in every elections they have to defend their deeds. If the political system is not derailed by power-hungry generals, the relatively few corrupt politicians can easily be purged by the democratic process.

hasankhan said:
cases should be reopen but if not proven relative people should be compensated and the people who filed these fake cases should be put in jails.

logical said:
In last sixty years only last PPP govt was corrupt. Other all generals, politicians are clean and most important thing is these cases registered by most honest general Mushraf.
شرم تم کو مگر نہیں اتی

• Is it not the type of NRO in past and future
* In proposed Balochistan package people will be release from jail and all the cases against them will be withdraw and many of them openly admitted that they are doing arm struggle.
*In coming years Taliban will be part of Afghan govt and thousands of Pakistani Taliban will be in political process without any sentences.
*In 1977 military operation in balochistan stopped after five years. All prisoners released. No general or political activist who was openly involved in arm struggle blame for any thing.
*Nawaz family with a deal with Mushraf went to Saudi Arab.
*In history of trade union thousand times after strikes when management and trade union sit on table for agreement first it decided all charge sheets will be withdrawn.
*Pholan davi, a proved dacoit in India got mercy and became Lock Saba member.
*Every dictator in Pakistan got approval for breaking constitution, from assessable.
*when Ayub khan went thousands political activist was in jail with true and false FIR but next day they start releasing them. Same thing happened when Bhutto gone.

All above example are proved crimes not only political but murders, treason etc. this NRO is nothing to do with proved cases even in some cases more then 11 years within two different governments.

If supreme court can say that last supreme court made mistake and their action null and void then if National assembly decide that the approval of ( Mushraf 12th October coup and first PCO ) was wrong and it is null and void then what going to be happened with Ch Iftikhar.
You can find hundreds example in our and in world history where for breaking stalemate with political understanding we have to do this. Opposition for NRO is not about eliminating corruption. This is a political agenda. Generals have no problems with politician’s corruption instead they encourage them so they can blackmail them. Why they hate Zardari? He is trying to make good relation with India and interested in supremacy of civil govt on Military. Fortunate of Pakistani people Nawaz sharif (not all Muslim league) also have same vision. Most of these people are not democrat in nature. They can not remove him democratically so remove him by NRO, by court or by military.

mir munsif said:
..the propaganda and hate compaign against PPP is very old.Mighty establishment and sponsors always tried to corner PPP,the biggest federal party of Pakistan.Inspite of all their efforts of infusing hate and fabricating new cases against PPP,they could not erase the name of PPP.Even today,if elections held,if PPP wont stand as majority party,I assure u,it would be Second largest.

Actually Military Economic Umpire and co sponsors dont want to give free space to democratic system because they fear it,If it succeeds,which will weaken their power control over state.Its war started by Military Alliance (Certain Media+Mullas+agencies+Certain class in bureacracy etc) against PPP led Govt to discredit Govt so that they can cut the roots of democracy.Wake up call for Pro-democratic forces!!

dara said:

Bravo , Bravo pakistanies from whole of Lahore only Jahangir Badar was corrupt all others are angels. Those whose names are not in NRO are the real culprits because they belong to Punjabi Establishment.

In Lahore where since 1990 we only saw Muslim League in power thus all the corruption was done by them only JB . Hamayoon Akhtar Khan, Mian Munir, Haji Maqsood Butt, Liaqat baluch, Salman butt, and numarous Muslim League MPas and MNA’s no matter they were Q or N or XYZ.

Army generals the most corrupt people along with Punjabi establishment and Muslim League are the real culprits.

Nawaz Sharief family are bunch of saints who become the most richest just with hard work and by praying five times. The state pakistan has no courege to make cases against punjabi leaders. This will take Pakistan to its logical end , disintegration.

Pakistan said:
=============================================================
Be realistic….DO NOT BE TRAPD IN THE PROPAGANDA DONE BY THESE JOKERS.
=============================================================
The following are the only clean people in the country.
1: NS
2: CHs.
3: Army Generals,Colns,Capt. etc as they all are living according to theor means.
———–
Case against Rehman A Malik: Illegal detention against complainant and gratfication.
Source: http://www.geo.tv/important_events/2009/nrolist/pages/list.asp
———-
My suggestion to AZ to resign and go to the courts to get clearance.
———
To me: 95% people in NRO will be freed.
———

mir munsif said:
More Corruption stories

Pakistan-armys-multimillionaires

http://politicalpakistan.blogspot.com/2006/01/pakistan-armys-multimillionaires.html

Army Eyes its Biggest Real Estate Catch in Hotbed Islamabad

http://www.satribune.com/archives/200503/P1_butt2.htm

One more corruption story:

High Court Presented With Massive Charge Sheet Against Pakistan Army

http://www.satribune.com/archives/aug10_16_03/P1_chargesheet.htm

mir munsif said:
Pakalert Report update to share you!

EXPOSED!!!

GEO TV, Kamran Khan and the Lies of Dr Shahid Masood

http://pakalert.wordpress.com/2009/09/05/geo-tv-kamran-khan-and-the-lies-of-dr-shahid-masood/

Bawa said:
صدر کیخلاف مقدمات ختم ہو چکے: ترجمان

لاہور /اسلام آباد/ (خبرنگار خصوصی نوائے وقت +خصوصی نامہ نگارنوائے وقت + ریڈیو نیوز) ایوان صدر کے ترجمان فرحت اللہ بابر نے کہا ہے کہ قانون کے تحت صدر زرداری کیخلاف جو کیس ثابت نہیں ہو سکے اور جن کی انوسٹی گیشن ہو رہی ہے وہ ختم ہو چکے ہیں۔ نوائے وقت سے گفتگو کرتے ہوئے انہوں نے کہا اگر عدالتیں اس حوالے سے کوئی دوسرا فیصلہ کرتی ہیں تو وہ ہمکارے لئے قابل قبول ہو گا۔ امریکہ میں پاکستانی سفیر حسین حقانی نے کہا ہے کہ میں نے کبھی این آر او سے فائدہ نہیں اٹھایا۔ میری سمجھ میں نہیں آتا میرا نام این آر او سے فائدہ اٹھانے والوں کی فہرست میں کیسے آ گیا۔ انہوں نے کہا احتساب بیورو نے جو مقدمات میرے خلاف بنائے تھے وہ میں نے عدالتوں سے کلیئر کرا لئے تھے۔ مزید براں پیپلز پارٹی کے سیکرٹری جنرل جہانگیر بدر نے فہرست کو مسترد کرتے ہوئے کہا کہ این آر او سے فائدہ اٹھانے والے کوئی اور ہونگے۔ میرے مقدمات ہائیکورٹ میں ہیں۔ انہوں نے کہا میرے فیصلے کی گھڑی آئی تو میرا نام این آر او میں شامل کر دیا گیا۔ ہم عدالتوں سے گھبرانے والے نہیں‘ مقدمات کا بھرپور دفاع کرینگے۔ پیپلز پارٹی کی سیکریٹری اطلاعات فوزیہ وہاب نے کہا ہے کہ عدالت کو ایسے فیصلے ریورس نہیں کرنے چاہئیں جس سے ملک کا مفاد اور موجودہ نظام متاثر ہو ۔ نجی ٹی وی سے گفتگو میں انہوں نے کہا کہ پیپلزپارٹی مقدمات سے گھبرانے والی نہیں پارٹی رہنماؤں نے ہمیشہ عدالتوں کا سامنا کیا ہے۔ انہوں نے کہا کہ این آر او سے فائدہ اٹھانے والوں کی فہرست پہلے ہی جاری کردینا چاہیے تھی اس میں تاخیر کی گئی۔ ان کا کہنا تھا کہ اکثر مقدمات انتقامی کارروائی کے تحت بنائے گئے

Pakistan said:
After November 28, Nobody will be able to comment on this NRO issue.

As far far as These jokers (from Mullah Media Alliance) are concerned, They will damage the country by spreading false information and propaganda.

Ansar Abasi once mntined that PM stoped AZ to fire COA which was totally wrong and there was no fact at all.Think about the consequences in sight for the vicious propganda and If COA had taken this seriously.

Same thing applied with Saleh Zafar,a biggest joker,Once spread the news that AZ offered 5 crore each MNA to cast a vote in favour of NRO,What the hek this news analyst is?
This Jang group is trying to become a new piller in the country as they think it was the Jang newsgroup brought Musharaf don hence they can do this with each and every governament.
DEFEAT IS YOUR FATE YOU ALL JOKERS…….

mir munsif said:
I am neither against healthy criticism nor I ever consider PPP as Party of angels.Having said that I am also against Biased and abusive approach against PPP and its leadership.Even as per Transparency International and many independent fact finding reports,the Biggest plunders of national assets are Military Establishment Umpire.They are looting it without any accountability and any check & balance and any time they can over throw democratic system on the basis of so called ‘Biggest national interest’..while they are also considered Pure ppl of Pakistan.

Its important to understand the bigger picture,The weakness of any party or democratic system gives stimulus or rejuvenate the role of Military Authority.Since the day one,The Military Alliance has captured the authority over state and they WONT ever allow any Federal party or leadership to earn good names or strengthen the democratic system.It is indeed War of interests between Democratic Camp Vs Military Alliance (Military+Intelligence agencies+Certain Media+Pseduo Political groups+Mullas etc).

Politicians have suffered more and earned bad name,while the Military Alliance have earned not only good name but also plundered at the extreme.Give a break please,whether good or bad,Politicians have to go through democratic process,which may be slow but sooner or later,it will reform,but the wekaness of Political parties should not be an EXECUSE for any Military QUO.Therefore,I suggest you all to be free to criticize any party or leadership but dont be blind in hate/biased mind..dont be a tool of Propaganda Industry of Agencies and Media co which have only objective to discredit Democratic system.

zahidnaqvi said:
The TIME for serious thinking has now arrived. We must admit that due to our religious thinking and attachments, certain communities and regions have blindly voted for Bhuttto Party, and believe me we all are suffering very badly now. In view of Transparency International Report we have been down-graded by 5 points and this is only due to NRO and widespread corrruption.

The corruption is to such a high level that even if you need a new gas or electricity connection you have to bribe from an ordinary office clerk, then SDO and then XEN.

Yes, this corruption has been in ALL previous Govt’s, but my God why is it ‘free for all’ situation when Bhutto Party rules. Peoples Party must change its name to Bhutto Family Corruption Party.

What really annoys me is that for the last few weeks, Zardari has now started to wear Sindhi topi. I personally saw that news item when 2 days ago at Kabul Airport he was wearing Sindhi topi. Zardari must come to his senses, he is now trying to fight Sindhi against Punjabi, and Shia against Sunni. We must now allow this to happen. I urge to all Zardari lovers that they must come to their senses. This latest list of beneficiaries has been prepared by Zardari’s own hand picked PM and this list contains 90% Sindhhi’s.

In the last 2 Govt of Benazir, Sindhi’s were particulary given jobs in PIA, Customs, Airport Immigration, huge loans in the name of Agricultural Loans, free umrah tickets etc. I am not saying that the then Punjab Govt of Pervaiz Elahi was an angel, but the level of corruption with the aid of MQM was at a very high level in Sindh.

mir munsif said:
@Zahid Naqvi

U Said “This latest list of beneficiaries has been prepared by Zardari’s own hand picked PM and this list contains 90% Sindhhi’s.”

I refute ur claims that 90 percent are Sindhis instead the right Phrase should be 90 percent are from SINDH.Dont play with fire of ethncity.

List contains names of only 34 politicians out of a total of 8,000.Only four Sindhi Political figures got benefit from NRO (AZ,Nusrat Bhutto,Agha Siraj Durani,Yusuf Talpur),14 Politicians are from Punjab.The Biggest beneficiary of NRO is MQM not Sindhis…Mind the GAP Please.

Your second claim about Sindhi topi,which creates trouble for you,seeing a President wearing Sindhi cap as if its some cap from India or Jews.Give a break man,President AZ wears this cap on many official events even on the day he took oath as President.Why A sindhi cap gives u suffocation,why you see always boiling Ethenic divide.SIndhis are equal stake holders of this state,who were the first ppl in Indo Sub continent to pass the Pakistan resolution bill in Assembly before prepartition,they always voted for Federal Parties,either PPP or PMLN etx,then why again some ppl want to corner them.Dont Push harder or play with fire,I am sure,if PPP ever lost its strength in Sindh,then if u know the dynamics of Sindh,No other party has any base nor they try to make their foundation…how many times NS or Imran khan visited Sindh…??Except PPP,other strong thriving forces are Nationalists.I personally feel that Sindh can turn another Baluchistan the day PPP loose its credibility in Sindh,coz other credible force left is Nationalists.

mir munsif said:
@Zahid Naqvi,

I respect your opinion but I appreciate if you enlighten us on healthy discussion and pointing out problems with solutions rather fueling Hate,ethnicity and launching personal attacks on PPP leadership through this platform.Grow up dude..Your Qazi sb’s vote bank is less than 5 Percent and every one knows whts their strength and even you will know in future elections where your JI stands

with all Military Mulla alliance Might and propaganda,they could not erase the name of PPP.Keep bashing and shouting as long as you can,coz this wont harm the vote bank of PPP,it will absolutly give some blood pressure to u SInce your agenda seems to find all sort of blames upon PPP and all evils are in PPP while the rest of parties and Military Mullas are angels ..

runaway said:
when is Shahid Masood going to discuss Kiyani’s role in NRO.

Shouldn’t he also resign for his role in NRO?

I dont like Zardari but he is easy punching bag. Just by getting rid of one person won’t fix problems of Pakistan

Read more...

Friday, 13 November 2009

‘Sharifs used paper mill to whiten money’ - Ishaq Dar's confession



By Azaz Syed
Friday, 13 Nov, 2009
Dawn

Senator Ishaq Dar, while accusing Nawaz and Shahbaz Sharif of money laundering, also implicated himself by confessing in the court that he had opened fake foreign currency accounts in different international banks.

ISLAMABAD: The Musharraf government prepared a money laundering reference against PML-N leaders Mian Nawaz Sharif and Mian Shahbaz Sharif in 2000 on the basis of a statement recorded by one of their trusted lieutenants, Senator Ishaq Dar, according to a court document seen by Dawn here on Thursday.

Senator Dar’s handwritten statement, given before a magistrate back on April 25, 2000, had alleged that Sharif brothers used the Hudaibya Paper Mills as cover for money laundering during the late 1990s.

The reference was prepared on the orders of then president Pervez Musharraf, but it was shelved after the Sharif brothers went into exile in December of the same year.

The Musharraf government tried to reopen the reference in 2007 after Nawaz Sharif announced his return to the country.

The confessional statement of Senator Ishaq Dar was recorded before a district magistrate in Lahore. He was brought to the court from a jail by Basharat Shahzad, who was then serving as assistant director in the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA).

According to legal experts, the senator’s deposition was an `irrevocable statement’ as had been recorded under section 164 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).

Senator Ishaq Dar has always been regarded as one of the closest aides of the Sharif family, and is now also a relative as his son is married to Nawaz Sharif’s younger daughter.

However, the NAB record clearly shows that back in 2000 he had agreed to give a written statement against the Sharifs about their alleged involvement in money laundering.

The top PML-N leaders had hit a rough patch by then as some of their lieutenants were busy developing a new political system for Gen Pervez Musharraf after his Oct 1999 military coup.

In the statement, Ishaq Dar accused Nawaz and Shahbaz Sharif of money laundering in the Hudaibiya Paper Mills case.

At one point in the 43-page statement, Mr Dar said that on the instructions of Mian Nawaz Sharif and Shahbaz Sharif, ‘I opened two foreign currency accounts in the name of Sikandara Masood Qazi and Talat Masood Qazi with the foreign currency funds provided by the Sharif family in the Bank of America by signing as Sikandara Masood Qazi and Talat Masood Qazi’.

He said that all instructions to the bank in the name of these two persons were signed by him under the orders of ‘original depositors’, namely Mian Nawaz Sharif and Mian Shahbaz Sharif.

‘The foreign currency accounts of Nuzhat Gohar and Kashif Masood Qazi were opened in Bank of America by Naeem Mehmood under my instructions (based on instructions of Sharifs) by signing the same as Nuzhat Gohar and Kashif Masood Qazi.’

The document shows Dar stated that besides these foreign currency accounts, a previously opened foreign currency account of Saeed Ahmed, a former director of First Hajvari Modaraba Co and close friend of Dar, and of Mussa Ghani, the nephew of Dar’s wife, were also used to deposit huge foreign currency funds provided by ‘the Sharif family’ to offer them as collateral to obtain different direct and indirect credit lines.

Senator Dar had disclosed that the Bank of America, Citibank, Atlas Investment Bank, Al Barka Bank and Al Towfeeq Investment Bank were used under the instructions of the Sharif family.

Interestingly enough, Ishaq Dar also implicated himself by confessing in court that he — along with his friends Kamal Qureshi and Naeem Mehmood — had opened fake foreign currency accounts in different international banks.

Mr Dar said an amount of $3.725 million in Emirates Bank, $ 8.539 million in Al Faysal Bank and $2.622 million were later transferred in the accounts of the accounts Hudaibya Paper Mills.

He said that the entire amount in these banks finally landed in the accounts of the paper mills.

The Hudaibiya Paper Mills case is still pending in the National Accountability Bureau.
If it is opened again, the Sharif brothers may be in for a rude shock: a confidant is to blame for the albatross around their necks.

In this regard Dawn made repeated efforts to contact Senator Dar on telephone, but without luck as his mobile number was switched off and he did not reply to text messages.

However, a PML-N spokesman Siddiq ul Farooq alleged that the signed statement was extracted from Mr Ishaq Dar under duress.


‘NAB report dents Nawaz Sharif’s stance on NRO’

LAHORE: Rashed Rahman, renowned analyst and Editor of the Daily Times, has said that the recent money laundering scandal of Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) chief Nawaz Sharif and Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif revealed in the documents of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) has damaged the so-called moral stance of the Sharifs on the National Reconciliation Ordinance (NRO).

Talking to a private television channel, he said that no body had the moral high grounds amongst the political class of the Pakistan, as they were all involved in scandals including the Sharifs. Rahman said that PML-N leader Ishaq Dar had confessed to the money laundering of the Sharifs viz-a-viz the Hudabia Paper Mills case, saying he could not deny the confessional statement of Sharif’s confidant and accountant-en-chief, Ishaq Dar.

Rahman said the same statement of Ishaq Dar was lying with NAB since 2000, and wondered as to why this report had been suppressed for so long. (Daily Times)

Read more...

Saturday, 7 November 2009

Nawaz Sharif's (temporary) NRO for the wife of Yusuf Raza Gilani

After the "minus one" campaign, do you know who will be the next in line? Yes, it will be our very dear, (apparently) acceptable to Nawaz Sharif and ISI, Prime Minister Yusuf Raza Gilani.

It was thus observed in an editorial of The News (8 Nov 09): "As speculation about the imminent downfall of the president grows in volume and pitch, with more and more people convinced that Mr Asif Ali Zardari is headed out of the towering gates of the presidential palace he moved into just over a year ago, it seems to have suddenly dawned on the prime minster that he must do all he can to save himself. While Mr Yusuf Raza Gilani has been quite willing, for some months, to play along with those who would like to see the back of Mr Zardari, he now seems conscious of the fact that the same elements may see no need to allow him to retain his post either. The 'minus-one' formula we have heard so much about since the middle of the year may not turn into the 'minus-342' move the Punjab governor has spoken of. But its impact could expand beyond the presidency and draw into the churning whirlpool the prime minster and his government. While Mr Zardari has been drawing much of the flak for the paralysis we see in government, and indeed he has been partially responsible for this by intervening in decision-making at every level, the cabinet must accept a significant chunk of responsibility for failing to get things moving in any meaningful direction."

Here is a glimpse of the ammunition that will be used against the Gilani sahib of Multan Sharif.

According to recent media reports, the NAB withdrew two cases against Fauzia Gilani and others who received Rs71.480 million from the Agricultural Development Bank of Pakistan in 1987. Two years later, the same tola milked the same bank for another Rs100.200 million. After grabbing Rs171.680 million in a span of 24 months, Mrs Gilani (actually, could it be Mr Gilani?) and her five business partners scooted--I mean, defaulted. The timing for defaulting was ideal – it was the reign of Benazir Bhutto and Gilani was in her cabinet.

Today, fate again favours Gilani making him our prime minister and the NAB favours him by forgiving his wife the default.




'Out, damned spot'!

Saturday, November 07, 2009 (The News)
Anjum Niaz

"All the perfumes of Arabia will not sweeten this little hand," cried Lady Macbeth after killing Duncan, king of Scotland, in Shakespeare's Macbeth. Fast-forward four centuries. We know that all the laws in the world, not even the NRO, can wash clean the corruption of our leaders, both in the government and the opposition. The media, like Macbeth's three witches, brews up toxicants while dancing around a cauldron boiling over with 100 corruption cases of the president and his cronies. Chanting "Fair is foul and foul is fair," the witches (read: the media) are foreshadowing events to come, predicting the evil that will cloud the president's judgment in pursuing the passing of the NRO by Parliament.

The president blocked the restoration of Chief Justice Iftikhar Chaudhry till the end. He feared the chief justice would never give him and his friends a free pass for their alleged corruption. Today, a nation of 180 million is crying out for justice. Our only hope is the Supreme Court. My Lords, dispense swift justice in dispatching the NRO and make sure the beneficiaries receive exemplary punishment.

The pots meanwhile have started calling the kettles black. "All parties benefited from the National Reconciliation Ordinance; it also helped people (the Sharif brothers) who had been exiled for 10 years to return to Pakistan under a deal," Sindh chief minister Qaim Ali Shah is reported as saying. "These NRO beneficiaries are now playing politics," Shah said, referring to Nawaz Sharif's rejection of the NRO.

If the system has to be cleaned, let there be accountability across the board. It's not only the PPP godfathers who stole from a beaten nation, but leaders of all political parties, civil and military scofflaws. Go get them all.

Among those whose past must be made transparent is the prime minister's wife, our First Lady. The media is airbrushing Gilani as the next in succession to Zardari. But there are skeletons rattling in his cupboard. One of them is the stuffing of undeserving people in the National Assembly Secretariat. An NAB official dealing with the case gave me glaring examples of how Yusuf Raza Gilani had "reprehensibly" misused his position as Speaker. The official has all the records, but they are worthless because his bosses at the grandly called National Accountability Bureau have unashamedly caved in to the prime minister and withdrawn two bank-default cases against Mrs Fauzia Gilani and five others. They settled "out of court," we're told.

According to recent media reports, the NAB withdrew two cases against Fauzia Gilani and others who received Rs71.480 million from the Agricultural Development Bank of Pakistan in 1987. Two years later, the same tola milked the same bank for another Rs100.200 million. After grabbing Rs171.680 million in a span of 24 months, Mrs Gilani (actually, could it be Mr Gilani?) and her five business partners scooted--I mean, defaulted. The timing for defaulting was ideal – it was the reign of Benazir Bhutto and Gilani was in her cabinet.

Today, fate again favours Gilani making him our prime minister and the NAB favours him by forgiving his wife the default.

"Surely these loans, including the principal amount as well as the accumulated mark-up for the past many years, must have been repaid," writes Brig (retd) Farooq Hameed Khan, a former NAB consultant in Lahore. "If this has really happened, it is unbelievable in a country like Pakistan where the rich and powerful do not normally return bank loans. This 'mother of all settlements' should be made public for all others to follow this historic and rare gesture by the country's top elite," he says.

We have a right to ask about the reported "out-of-court settlement" between the First Lady and the NAB.


The writer is a freelance journalist with over twenty years of experience in national and international reporting. Email: aniaz@fas.harvard.edu ; www.anjumniaz.com

Read more...

Monday, 28 September 2009

Good instincts are not enough, Mr Zardari!


Good instincts are not enough
Monday, September 28, 2009 (The News)

Talat Masood

The country faces an extraordinary situation. No one trusts its top political leadership. The print and electronic media is in overdrive to give it a bad name and some commentators are leading the onslaught against President Zardari. The politics of negativism is gaining ascendancy. The media no doubt are justified in criticising some of his actions, but it has personalised the issue and brought in lot of subjectivity and emotion. President Zardari is stonewalling the criticism by ignoring it, not realising that it creates despondency among the public.

Clearly, Nawaz Sharif has gained a lot in popular standing but is not in a position to challenge Zardari for a show-down. The PML (N) realises that any attempt on their part to dislodge the government will undermine the system and encourage the army to reassert politically. Nawaz Sharif is also aware of the sensitivities of the smaller provinces as any move on his part to destabilise the government could be perceived as an attempt by “Punjab-military axis” to deny smaller provinces their right to being equal partners in the federation.

The army has learnt its lesson that military take-overs have cost the army and the country heavily. Its extensive involvement in counterinsurgency operations and the fact that militants will be emboldened if the army assumes political control is a major deterrent against any adventurism. Foreign countries, especially the US and the western powers, will react strongly to military rule and Pakistan’s isolation will increase manifold. At the domestic level the judiciary will not provide the usual legal cover. Moreover, General Kayani would like to stay away from political power. This however, does not imply that the military will be indifferent to widespread corruption and a deteriorating law and order situation.

Similarly, it would be imprudent on part of President Zardari to take Washington for granted. The United States is investing heavily in terms of financial assistance, political capital and military resources and will not tolerate the squandering away of its assistance to bad governance and massive corruption. President Zardari is well advised to draw lessons from how Karzai brought Afghanistan on the brink of a chasm and his own reputation to an all-time low. The fight against Taliban has been the first casualty of the inept handling by Karzai.

If the president will not make a serious effort to improve his reputation by countering rumours of corruption, they will stick and largely neutralise the benefits of US assistance and goodwill. Above all, it will be sad if Pakistan once again misses this great historic opportunity by failing to capitalise on the prevailing international goodwill.

It is also true that cynicism, prejudices and a simplistic black and white approach towards issues blinds us from seeing the positive side of our leaders. Surprisingly, in many areas, the president’s instincts are right. His unambiguous and categorical stand on terrorism and extremism, support to the military in counter-insurgency operations and the desire to promote good relations with India and Afghanistan must be given credit.

President Zardari’s visits to China every quarter have been a subject of ridicule. But again, if seen in the context of China as an ascending global economic and military power, developing multi-faceted economic and strategic linkages with it could be extremely rewarding. One can surely fault him for micro-managing some of the business transactions which is not his job. He should be giving general direction and then leave the implementation to the relevant functionaries. There is a growing demand on him to conduct the affairs of the state in a more transparent manner and invoke institutional accountability all around to improve his credibility.

His idea to have the “Friends of Pakistan” forum can turn out to be a useful instrument for the assembled countries to assist Pakistan. The country needs political support and economic assistance, and this is an excellent platform for doing the same.

The president should, however, know that it is not enough to have good instincts unless they are matched by a coherent vision. He needs to translate his instincts into an overarching vision and then market it to the nation. His working mostly outside the normal institutional framework of the government does not help in improving his credibility or the image of the country. The indictment of Transparency International coinciding with the “Friends of Pakistan” meeting will only reinforce the apprehensions that our leaders are engaged in personal aggrandisement and personal vanity.

It is fleeting moment and we have to use it to the best advantage by engaging in nation-building tasks. President Zardari and the current leadership will be judged by the people only by these criteria.

The writer is a retired lieutenant-general. Email: talat@comsats.net.pk

Read more...

Friday, 25 September 2009

Nawaz Sharif, Shahbaz Sharif and the Sugar Crisis in Pakistan


More than 50 percent sugar mills in Pak owned by politicians
August 23rd, 2009 - 6:22 pm ICT by ANI

Islamabad, Aug.23 (ANI): More than 50 percent of sugar mills in Pakistan are owned by political leaders, and despite this fact, sugar prices in the country have sky rocketed in the recent past, increasing problems for the people, especially in the month of Ramazan.

According to sources, there are 78 sugar mills in the country and the political leaders or their relatives or partners own more than 50 per cent of these factories.

Insiders said that there are at least six mills owned by President Asif Ali Zardari’s family members and other PPP leaders.

They also revealed that former Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s family members own nine sugar factories situated in different part of the country, most of them in Punjab province.

While the government has claimed that it would look that the sugar prices in the country do not exceed a limit, people believe it is difficult to bring down the prices and they would continue to suffer.

“When the government says that it will catch the culprits and provide sugar to the masses on affordable rates, it is like throwing dust in the eyes of masses”, The Nation quoted one Islamabad resident, as saying on conditions of anonymity.

“After all who were the ultimate beneficiaries of the meetings held between sugar mills owners and the government?” he asked.

The prime reason behind the sudden steep rise in the price of one of the most important daily commodity is a calculated strategy chalked out by major players of the sugar industry with help from important government personalities.

According to sources, the sugar mafia in the country has undermined orders from the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) and has manipulated decision-making at the Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP) to achieve the mischievous target of increasing the sugar prices.

The command with which this mafia works can be gauged from the fact that ECC’s order to release sugar at a controlled price of 38 rupees per kilogram through ration stores and utility shops is yet to be implemented and people have no choice but to shell out 55 to 60 rupees for a kilogram of sugar.

This is not the first time that sugar prices have reached sky high in Pakistan. During former President General Pervez Musharraf’s regime sugar prices had touched the then peak of 35 rupees per kilogram.A probe was ordered against the political big wigs close to the Musharraf government at that time. However, charges were dropped later on Musharraf’s personal request.

Observers believe that the current scam would also subside with time forcing Pakistanis to spend much more on sugar this Ramzan. (ANI)

http://www.thaindian.com/newsportal/south-asia/more-than-50-percent-sugar-mills-in-pak-owned-by-politicians_100236802.html

Sugar Mills of Sharif Brothers exposed in Capital Talk -

See Hanif Abbasi (Jamaatia Munafiq) hypocritically defending his masters.

....
Sugar price

Friday, September 25, 2009

SC refuses to suspend LHC verdict ;Rejects pleas against order ; NAB report on sugar crisis presented in court; SBP gave sugar mills loans worth Rs55 billion out of which Rs21bn still outstanding, apex court told


By Sohail Khan

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court on Thursday rejected pleas of the sugar mills associations to suspend the order of the Lahore High Court that had fixed the price of sugar at Rs40 per kilogram.

Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, who heads the two-member bench of the apex court hearing identical petitions of the sugar mills associations against the LHC verdict, said the sugar price would remain Rs40 a kilogram.

The Pakistan Sugar Mills’ Association (PSMA), the Punjab Sugar Dealers’ Association (PSDA) and the federal and provincial governments had moved the Supreme Court against the September 3 verdict of the Lahore High Court (LHC) that had fixed retail price of sugar at Rs40 per kilogram.

They had prayed to the apex court to suspend the LHC verdict till the decision of the petitions. The Lahore High Court (LHC) on September 3, 2009 while taking suo motu notice of the sugar crisis in Punjab had fixed the retail price of sugar at Rs40 per kilogram.

In compliance with the court’s earlier direction, the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) on Thursday presented a report prepared two years back on the sugar crisis. The report, prepared on February 17, 2006, stated that the bureau had carried out only preliminary investigation into the crisis but various quarters raised a lot of hue and cry giving the impression that NAB’s inquiry was contributing to further escalation of the sugar prices. This forced the NAB to close the inquiry, the report stated.

The report further stated the sugar industry in the country was predominantly owned by politicians, who despite being in government, acted contrary to the laws and ethics of business and held sugar stock which is tantamount to hoarding.

The report also contains a list of mills owned by politicians that hoarded thousands of metric tons of sugar during the 2006 crisis.It also states that there was a clear-cut position drawn by sugar mills owned by politicians and farmer associations while the government remained in a fix and lacked resolve to bridge the gap between the two stakeholders.

According to the NAB report of 2006, major ownership of the country’s sugar mills industry was in the hands of politicians who hoarded the commodity, which caused the sugar crisis.The report issued on February 17, 2006 also listed names of politicians who own sugar mills. They included Asif Ali Zardari (3 mills), the Sharif brothers (12 mills), Humayun Akhtar Khan, Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain, Mian Azhar, Mian Altaf Salim, Jehangir Tarin, Haroon Akhtar, Anwar Cheema and Nasrullah Dreshak.

A report submitted by the State Bank before the apex court stated that during January 2009, the banks gave sugar mills loans worth Rs55 billion of which Rs21 billion are still to be paid by the mills.

The court adjourned the hearing till October 1, as other parties in the case including the federal and provincial governments, the Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP), the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) and the PSMA requested for more time to present reports that the Supreme Court had sought on the previous hearing of the case.

The chief justice also directed PSMA President Iskander Khan to present a copy of the letter he had written to Federal Minister for Food and Agriculture Nazar Muhammad Gondal on June 16, 2009.

Responding to an inquiry by the chief justice, Khan said he had written to the minister that they had sugar stock of two million metric tons. The chief justice reminded him that he had also written to the minister that the PSMA had sugar stock sufficient up to December 2009.

During the course of proceedings, the chief justice observed that the court had not barred anyone from crushing sugarcane.The Punjab government in its reply to the Supreme Court on fixing the sugar prices said the country is facing the crisis because the Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP) failed to import the commodity in time.

It further stated that the sugar dealers sold 63 per cent of their stock in the first nine months while 37 per cent stock was hoarded for profiteering prior to the beginning of the crushing season. It said no formal inquiry was conducted on a report based on NAB investigation and the Supreme Court, taking suo motu action, dismissed the case on January 24, 2008.
http://www.thenews.com.pk/top_story_detail.asp?Id=24684
.....

PML-N rejects NAB report on sugar

Friday, 25 Sep, 2009
How can the Sharifs be held responsible for the sugar crisis in 2006 when they were in exile: says Senator Pervaiz Rashid.

LAHORE: Senator Pervaiz Rashid has said the National Accountability Bureau report about involving the Sharif brothers in 2006-07 sugar crisis was to stop the return of PML-N leaders to Pakistan and a tactic to blackmail them.

Commenting on the NAB report published after three years, the senator said that it was an era of dictatorship when the PML-N had issued a schedule of the All Parties Conference, Charter of Democracy and return of Nawaz Sharif to the country.

According to a press release issued here on Thursday, he said that all these tactics were adopted to create hurdles in the return of the exiled politicians.

He said the report about the sugar crisis against the PML-N leaders was a part of the character assassination campaign launched by the dictator.

It was the period when former president Pervez Musharraf was feared of public reaction against him and was not ready to give permission to prominent opposition leaders to play their political role, he said.

‘How can the Sharifs be held responsible for the sugar crisis in 2006 when they were in exile’, he questioned and added that they were not even allowed to perform funeral rituals of their father by the dictator.

The senator said that Shahbaz Sharif was also not allowed to participate in the marriage ceremony of his daughter.

Mr Rashid said when Shahbaz Sharif came to Pakistan he was sent back to Saudi Arabia through another plane despite clear orders of the Supreme Court.

He said most of such cooked up reports, which were prepared only to please the higher authorities, were proved wrong in the court.

He said why the government at that time did not dare to publish the report about the sugar crisis if irregularities were identified in it.

The senator said the Sharif brothers had never been involved in hoarding or anti-people policies and the public support given to them in the last general election was a proof of the fact.



Read more...

Thursday, 17 September 2009

Is Nawaz Sharif willing to apply Article 6 to General Kayani and also some of his cronies within PML-N?


Article 6 can’t just apply to one man: Gilani

* PM says those who supported Musharraf are in cabinet and some of them have also joined PML-N
* Musharraf not given indemnity, convicted or pardoned, no question of deal

By Zulfiqar Ghuman


ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani said on Wednesday that Article 6 could not be applied to only one person, as there were several politicians in parliament who also supported former president Pervez Musharraf by voting for the 17th Amendment.

“I have no love lost for Musharraf ... if parliament decides to try him, I will be with parliament. Article 6 cannot be applied to one individual ... those who supported him are today in my cabinet and some of them have also joined the PML-N ... the MMA, the MQM and the PML-Q supported him ... this is why I have said that it is not doable,” said the prime minister while informally talking to editors and also replying to questions by journalists at an Iftar-dinner he had hosted for them.

On President Asif Zardari’s disclosure about a “negotiated settlement”, he said, “Parliament has so far not given indemnity to Musharraf, nor has he been convicted or pardoned, so there is no question of any deal.”

About the balance of power between the offices of president and prime minister, Gilani said, “If you refer to Article 58(2b), let me tell you that this article has become redundant ... a parliamentary committee is working on the constitutional package.” (Daily Times)

Nazir Naji's Analysis:

Abbas Ather's Analysis:

Defence, not deterrence
By Cyril Almeida
Friday, 18 Sep, 2009
Dictators have arrived on the scene when the politicians have discredited themselves and the people left searching for saviours. —File Photo
Dictators have arrived on the scene when the politicians have discredited themselves and the people left searching for saviours. —File Photo

HAS the PML-N jumped the shark in its purported quest to have Musharraf tried for treason? The plot has definitely taken a turn towards the ridiculous this week.

We, the people, are expected to believe that the PML-N is shocked, shocked that a ‘deal’ was struck with outside powers to guarantee Musharraf a safe exit. Snow White, aka the PML-N, can’t imagine a deal could be struck to, say, bail a prime minister out of jail, fly him across to luxurious exile in Saudi Arabia and then engineer his return to our ‘sovereign’ nation. Oh wait, isn’t that what happened to Nawaz Sharif, leader of Snow White?

Right, that was different. Different why, you ask? Because, y’know, that was Nawaz Sharif, leader of the people, a democratic would-be amirul momineen, heir to the throne of the Mughal emperors of yore, the greatest ruler since sliced bread, and did I mention, leader of the people? So it’s OK, gosh darn necessary even, for outside powers to ride to the rescue of Sharif because he’s different.

The only thing that is different though are the circumstances. The hunted has become the hunter and in the jungle of Pakistani politics he thinks he can smell blood. But in the smoke-and-mirrors game that is our politics, don’t be so sure that the victim is who you think it is. For some, the PML-N’s ‘try Musharraf’ cry sounds awfully like ‘get Zardari’.

With astonishing speed, Zardari’s indiscretion has ricocheted and become about him. Nothing less than the ‘independence and sovereignty’ of parliament has been undermined by Zardari, according to the PML-N. But don’t expect the PML-N to fire off angry missives about the ‘violation’ to the other parties involved. Perhaps to the Americans and the British, but definitely not the Saudis. Sharif knows what’s good for him, and invoking the ire of the Saudi king definitely isn’t.

Keeping Zardari under pressure though is good for Sharif, hence the PML-N’s alacrity in tabling a motion against him in the National Assembly. For those keeping track of the tit-for-tat game, we’re now in round three. Round one was the minus-one formula that rattled Zardari, round two was the raking up of Sharif’s past and now round three is about doing the dirty on Zardari and embarrassing him.

That doesn’t mean Sharif wouldn’t like to see Musharraf hanged, drawn and quartered. The bitterness is palpable despite Sharif’s denials; he isn’t one to forgive or forget the humiliation of being handcuffed and thrown into a dingy cell. But that is neither remarkable nor unprecedented.

Legend has it that Zia and his generals decided to hang ZAB because that proud, disdainful prime minister had made it clear he would hang them if he ever got the chance. And the bitterness between Leghari and the PPP lives on to this day, 13 years since BB’s man in the presidency dismissed her government. That’s just how politics is and we can’t do anything about personal enmities.

But what the rest of us on the outside and at the mercy of the politicians and their vendettas can do is at least understand when acting on those enmities is a good idea from a systemic perspective and when it isn’t.

If trying Musharraf and throwing him in jail – I personally am squeamish about the death penalty – can yield some good that outstrips the risk of damage to the democratic project, I’m all for it.

I never was a fan of Musharraf because a dictatorship isn’t the answer to the problems of our polity. Well-intentioned or ill-intentioned is beside the point for me. The fact is, our polity is diverse and fractious and for historical, social and political reasons a one-man show is bound to exacerbate the tensions in the federation. Ergo, a dictator is a bad idea in the long term.

(Arguably, in the short term, a dictatorship may help reset the balance to keep the country in a low-level equilibrium rather than keel over from the depredations of the civilian political class, but that is a separate issue and, in any case, should the point not be to break out of a low-level political, economic and social equilibrium?)

But I just can’t see how prosecuting Musharraf will set a good precedent and buttress the democratic project in its present phase. Judging Musharraf guilty of treason in a court of law would be a precedent, absolutely, but what exactly would it achieve?

Deter the next dictator? Dictators have arrived on the scene when the politicians have discredited themselves and the people left searching for saviours. Ayub, Zia, Musharraf, each arrived when cynicism was at a peak.

It can be debated whether the public truly wanted a dictator at those points in time or whether the army had a hand in creating the political trouble in the first place, but the point is that deterrence – in the sense of threatening unacceptable costs to a would-be dictator – is not what is needed; a stronger defence is.

The deterrence, defence dichotomy is not mere word play, it is at the root of our present misguided national debate. There simply is no nuclear option to deter would-be dictators. Threaten to hang him and his cohorts? Right. The next adventurist general may just decide to hang all the politicians first and drag the country into a dark place we don’t even want to think about. Zia is the worst of the dictators we have had, but he isn’t the worst of all dictators we could have had.

A better bet, then, is to shore up the civilian political defences against a dictator. Build on the present transition to democracy. Incrementally push the army out of the governance and policy space. If there are 10 things a democratic government must have to be truly in charge and the army only allows it, say, two or three issues (education, health, the economy, whatever), then do those two or three things right and use the leverage to prise away more subjects from the army’s control.

And if the politicians must fight, fine. But do it within bounds. Zardari’s bid for power in Punjab was bad because of the way he attempted it by pouncing on Shahbaz Sharif’s disqualification and imposing governor’s rule. He could have tried to win a straight vote in the Punjab Assembly instead. And if Sharif wants to push for mid-term elections or defang Zardari, fine. But don’t do it in a roundabout way and flirt with invoking the army’s wrath at this delicate juncture in the transition to democracy.

A post-politics phase in which politicians on both sides of the aisle agree on everything and hug and kiss and hold each other’s hands is neither desirable nor beneficial to the democratic project.

What is needed though to build a solid defence against adventurist generals is selective cooperation. Zoom out and in the bigger picture politicians need to cooperate to defend the system against threats from rival institutions. Zoom in and they need to present alternatives on policies and different approaches to governance.

It’s not rocket science. But neither is it schoolboy stuff. And at the moment all we seem to have is a PML-N bent on throwing tantrums and chucking toys out of its pram and a PPP led by rank amateurs.

cyril.a@gmail.com (Dawn)


Read more...

Sunday, 13 September 2009

Nawaz Sharif versus Musharraf and the Saudi King: "Lussay da ki zore Muhammad?"


Tailpiece:

Musharraf’s trial not possible even in PML-N govt: Fazl

LAHORE: The Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) could not have put Gen (r) Pervez Musharraf on trial even if it were in power, a private TV channel quoted Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI-F) chief Fazlur Rehman as saying on Saturday. Fazl said his party had demanded Musharraf’s trial however, under the present circumstances there could be no trial at all. He said parliament’s performance was poor, as it has passed only one resolution regarding terrorism, but could not even implement that in letter and spirit. daily times monitor

نواز عبداللہ ملاقات: سیاسی گفتگوسے پرہیز

فائل فوٹو ، نواز شریف

مسلم لیگ نواز وفاقی حکومت سے پرویز مشرف کے خلاف آئین سے سنگین بغاوت کا مقدمہ قائم کرنے کا مطالبہ کر رہی ہے

پاکستان میں حزب اختلاف کی سب سے بڑی جماعت مسلم لیگ ن کے سربراہ میاں نواز شریف نے ہفتے اور اتوا کی درمیانی شب سعودی عرب کے فرمانروا شاہ عبداللہ سے ملاقات کی۔

شاہی محل میں ہونے والی اس ملاقات میں سابق وزیراعظم کے ہمراہ ان کے صاحبزادے حسین نواز اور اہم پارٹی راہنما اسحٰق ڈ ار بھی موجود تھے جبکہ سعودی کابینہ اور شاہی کابینہ کے بعض ارکان نے بھی رات بارہ بجے شروع ہونے والی اس ایک گھنٹہ طویل ملاقات میں شرکت کی۔

ملاقات میں موجود کسی راہنماء سے براہ راست رابطہ نہیں ہو سکا لیکن پاکستان میں موجود مسلم لیگی قیادت کا کہنا ہے کہ شاہ عبداللہ کے ساتھ پاکستانی سیاست سے جڑے کسی موضوع پر گفتگو نہیں ہوئی۔

واضح رہے کہ میاں نواز شریف اپنے اہل خاندان کے ہمراہ عمرے کی ادائیگی کے سلسلے میں گزشتہ ہفتے سعودی عرب روانہ ہوئے تھے جہاں چند روز قبل ہی ان کے مخالف سابق صدر پرویز مشرف نے بھی سعودی فرمانروا سے ملاقات کی تھی۔

ضمانت دی گئی ہے کہ پاکستان میں نواز شریف کی جماعت کے پرزور مطالبے کے باوجود ان پر بغاوت کا مقدمہ نہیں چلایا جائے گا

پرویز مشرف

پرویز مشرف نے بعد ازاں ایک پاکستانی ٹیلی وژن چینل کو انٹرویو میں کہا تھا کہ انہیں ضمانت دی گئی ہے کہ پاکستان میں نواز شریف کی جماعت کے پرزور مطالبے کے باوجود ان پر بغاوت کا مقدمہ نہیں چلایا جائے گا۔

مسلم لیگ نواز کے ترجمان پرویز رشید نے پارٹی سربراہ کی شاہ عبداللہ سے ملاقات کے حوالے سے صحافیوں کو بتایا کہ اس ملاقات میں پاکستانی سیاست پر کوئی براہ راست گفتگو نہیں ہوئی لیکن ملکی اور علاقائی سلامتی سے متعلق امور پر بات کی گئی۔ انہوں نے وضاحت نہیں کی کہ سلامتی امور سے ان کی مراد کیا ہے لیکن پرویز رشید نے بتایا کہ ملکی اقتصادی اور سیاسی استحکام کے بارے میں بھی بات کی گئی۔

’نواز شریف خطے کے اہم ترین سیاسی راہنما ہیں اور اس حوالے سے خطے میں سلامتی سے متعلق امور پر تبادلہ خیال کیا گیا۔‘

سیاسی تجزیہ کار اور بین الاقوامی تعلقات کے ماہر پروفیسر رسول بخش رئیس نے ملاقات کے بارے میں کہا کہ ’مشرف کے خلاف بغاوت کا مقدمہ چلانے کا براہ راست تعلق ملکی سیاسی استحکام سے بنتا ہے اس لیے یہ عین ممکن ہے کہ اس موضوع پر بھی اس ملاقات میں اگر براہ راست نہ سہی تو بلواسطہ بات کی گئی ہو۔‘

سعودی عرب میں گزشتہ چند روز میں شاہ عبداللہ کے ساتھ ہونے والی ان دو اہم ملاقاتوں (پرویز مشرف اور نواز شریف) کے بعد بظاہر اب ایسا لگتا ہے کہ پرویز مشرف پر بغاوت کا مقدمہ چلنے کے امکانات خاصے کم ہوگئے ہیں

رسول بخش رئیس

رسول بخش رئیس کا کہنا تھا کہ سعودی عرب میں گزشتہ چند روز میں شاہ عبداللہ کے ساتھ ہونے والی ان دو اہم ملاقاتوں (پرویز مشرف اور نواز شریف) کے بعد بظاہر اب ایسا لگتا ہے کہ پرویز مشرف پر بغاوت کا مقدمہ چلنے کے امکانات خاصے کم ہوگئے ہیں۔

واضح رہے کہ سابق وزیراعظم نواز شریف نے سنہ انیس سو ننانوے میں اپنی حکومت کا تختہ الٹنے والے فوجی سربراہ کے خلاف دو برس قبل اعلٰی عدلیہ کے ججوں کو برطرف کر کے ملک میں ایمرجنسی نافذ کرنے پر ان کے خلاف آئین سے سنگین بغاوت کا مقدمہ قائم کرنے کا مطالبہ کر رکھا ہے۔

آئین کے آرٹیکل چھ کے تحت آئین توڑنے والے کے خلاف سنگین بغاوت کا مقدمہ صرف وفاقی حکومت ہی دائر کر سکتی ہے۔

صدر مشرف کے ہاتھوں معزول ہونے والے چیف جسٹس افتخار محمد چوہدری کی زیر سربراہی سپریم کورٹ کے ایک بینچ نے ایمرجنسی کے خلاف اپنے فیصلے میں سابق صدر کو آئین کی خلاف ورزی کا مجرم قرار دے چکی ہے۔

اس کے باوجود وفاقی حکومت کی جانب سے سابق صدر پر بغاوت کا مقدمہ درج کرنے میں پس و پیش کرنے پر مسلم لیگ نواز اور حکومت کے درمیان کشیدگی کی فضا قائم ہے جس پر پرویز مشرف کے مطابق، سعودی فرمانروا نے اپنی تشویش کا اظہار کیا ہے کیونکہ ان کے بقول پاکستان میں اس نوعیت کی سیاسی کشیدگی موجودہ حالات میں ملکی استحکام اور معیشت کے لیے اچھا شگون نہیں ہے


بات نکلے گی تو دور تلک جائے گی

مشرف

سابق صدر نے ایکسپریس ٹی وی کو انٹرویو میں صاف صاف کہا کہ انہیں کوئی ہاتھ نہیں لگا سکتا

پاکستان میں بہت سارے لوگوں کو پہلے ہی شبہہ تھا کہ آئین توڑنے کے الزام میں سابق فوجی صدر پرویز مشرف کے خلاف نہ تو بغاوت کا مقدمہ چلےگا اور نہ ہی انہیں کوئی سزا ملے گی۔ لیکن سعودی عرب کے بادشاہ شاہ عبداللہ کی پرویز مشرف، میاں نواز شریف اور رحمٰن ملک سے ہونے والی حالیہ ملاقاتوں کے بعد یہ یقین ہوگیا ہے کہ سابق صدر کا احتساب اب دیوانے کا خواب بن گیا ہے۔

جن لوگوں کو سابق صدر پرویز مشرف کے خلاف کارروائی نہ ہونے کا شبہہ تھا ان کی دلیل یہ تھی کہ پاکستان میں دکھاوے کا حکمران کوئی بھی ہو لیکن اصل حکمرانی ’سیکیورٹی ایسٹیبلشمینٹ‘ کی ہے اور یہ کیسے ممکن ہے کہ ایک ’سیکورٹی سٹیٹ‘ میں فوج کے سابق سربراہ کے خلاف اتنا بڑا مقدمہ بنے؟

یہ پاکستان جیسے کئی ممالک کا المیہ ہے کہ وہاں ’قومی سلامتی‘ کی آڑ میں سیاہ و سفید کی مالک قوتوں کے اعلٰی افسر تو کجا ان کے کسی جونیئر افسر کے خلاف بھی سرکاری فرائض کے سلسلے میں ان کے خلاف مقدمہ چلے یا انہیں سزا ملے۔

آپ ’مڈنائٹ جیکالز‘ کو ہی دیکھ لیجئے کہ آج بھی سینہ ٹھوک کر کہتے ہیں کہ ’میں نے فلاں کو پیسہ دیا اور فلاں سے یہ کام کروایا‘۔ برگیڈیئر (ر) امتیاز عرف بِلا ہوں یا میجر ریٹائرڈ عامر، جو کچھ وہ اقرار کرچکے ہیں بھلا ان سے کسی نے پوچھا کہ یہ سب کچھ کیوں کیا یا اس میں کون سا قومی مفاد چھپا ہوا تھا؟۔

مجھے شاہ عبداللہ نے بھائی کہا ہے اور یہ یقین دلایا ہے کہ میاں نواز شریف میرے خلاف بغاوت کا مقدمہ چلانے کا مطالبہ نہیں کرے گا

پرویز مشرف

یہی وجہ ہے کہ پاکستان میں ایک نئی کہاوت زباں زد عام ہورہی کہ ’ٹریفک سگنل کی خلاف ورزی پر تو سزا ملے گی لیکن آئین توڑنے والوں کو سلامی ملے گی‘۔

جب سابق فوجی صدر پرویز مشرف کے خلاف بغاوت کا مقدمہ بنانے کی بات چلی اور دیکھتے ہی دیکھتے ایک طوفان اٹھا تو صدرِ پاکستان آصف علی زرداری نے وزیر داخلہ رحمٰن ملک کو راتوں رات اپنا خصوصی ایلچی بنا کر سعودی عرب روانہ کیا اور اگلے ہی روز بادشاہ سلامت نے لندن سے اپنے شاہی طیارے میں سابق صدر پرویز مشرف کو بھی بلا لیا۔ ان کی ملاقات کے بعد یہ خبریں بھی شائع ہوئیں کہ بادشاہ سلامت نے پرویز مشرف سے کہا ہے کہ وہ پاکستانی قوم سے معافی مانگیں اور سیاسی معاملات کے متعلق اپنی زبان بند رکھیں۔

لیکن اس کے ساتھ ساتھ یہ بھی خبریں آئیں کہ ایسی کوئی بات نہیں ہوئی بلکہ بادشاہ سلامت نے تو پرویز مشرف کو یقین دلایا ہے کہ ان کے خلاف کوئی کارروائی نہیں ہوگی۔ ایسی متضاد خبروں کی وجہ سے جو گو مگو والی صورتحال پیدا ہوئی وہ میاں نواز شریف کی شاہ عبداللہ سے ہونے والی ملاقات اور پرویز مشرف کے ایکسپریس ٹی وی کو دیے گئے انٹرویو سے واضح ہوگئی۔

سابق صدر نے انٹرویو میں صاف صاف کہا کہ انہیں کوئی ہاتھ نہیں لگا سکتا۔ ’مجھے شاہ عبداللہ نے بھائی کہا ہے اور یہ یقین دلایا ہے کہ میاں نواز شریف میرے خلاف بغاوت کا مقدمہ چلانے کا مطالبہ نہیں کریں گے‘۔ پرویز مشرف کے اس دعوے کی تاحال مسلم لیگ (ن) نے کوئی تردید نہیں کی۔ میاں نواز شریف کی اپنے صاحبزادے حسین نواز اور سمدھی اسحاق ڈار کے ہمراہ بادشاہ سلامت سے جو ملاقات ہوئی اس میں جو بھی بات چیت ہوئی اس کا علم تو انہیں ہی ہوگا۔

مشرف

’حکمران کوئی بھی ہو لیکن اصل حکمرانی ’سیکیورٹی سٹیبلشمینٹ‘ کی ہے‘

لیکن پرویز مشرف اور میاں نواز شریف سے ہونے والی ملاقات اور دونوں کو ملنے والے پروٹوکول کو اگر دیکھا جائے تو بظاہر پرویز مشرف کے دعوے کو تقویت ملتی ہے۔ پرویز مشرف کو لندن سے لانے کے لیے شاہی طیارہ بھیجا گیا اور چار گھنٹے کی طویل ملاقات ہوئی۔ جبکہ میاں صاحب کی ایک ہفتے تک سعودی عرب میں موجودگی کے باوجود ملاقات نہ ہونے پر ان کے ترجمان پرویز رشید نے پہلے کہا کہ یہ ان کا ’عبادتی دورہ‘ ہے اور میاں صاحب ہر سال اہل خانہ کے ہمراہ رمضان کے آخرے عشرے میں وہاں جاتے ہیں۔

جب ملاقات ہوئی تو ترجمان نے کہا کہ اس میں پاکستان کے سیاسی امور یا پرویز مشرف کے بارے میں کوئی بات نہیں ہوئی بلکہ ان کی ملکی اور علاقائی سلامتی کے امور پر بات ہوئی ہے۔ ان کا یہ بیان سن کر مجھے کراچی کے وہ ملباری ہوٹل یاد آئے جن کی دیواروں پر لکھا ہوتا ہے کہ ’یہاں سیاسی گفتگو کرنا منع ہے’۔ نصف شب کو ایک گھنٹے کی ملاقات جس میں نصف گھنٹہ عربی ترجمان کا نکالیں تو باقی نصف گھنٹہ اور اس میں بھی عافیت کا حصہ نکالیں تو باقی بچنے والے وقت میں تو صرف چند کلمات ہی بچتے ہیں۔ پتہ نہیں اس میں نصیحت تھی یا فرمائش، گزارش تھی یا کچھ اور۔

بحرحال میاں نواز شریف کی بادشاہ سلامت سے ہونے والی ملاقات کے بعد پرویز مشرف کا احتساب ممکن نہیں کیونکہ اس سارے تماشے میں اس بات کی بھی تقریباً تصدیق ہوگئی کہ موجودہ حکمرانوں نے عوامی طاقت کے بل بوتے پر پرویز مشرف کو نہیں نکالا بلکہ انہیں ان سے ایک اور ’ڈیل‘ کرنی پڑی اور اس نئے معاہدے کے ضامن بھی بظاہر سعودی عرب، امریکہ اور برطانیہ ہی معلوم ہوتے ہیں۔ اس سارے تماشے سے یہ بھی واضح ہوتا ہے کہ پاکستان اور اس کے کرتا دھرتا چاہے وہ سکرین پر ہوں یا پردے کے پیچھے وہ کتنے آزاد ہیں۔!!

پرویز مشرف کے احتساب کے معاملے میں سپریم کورٹ پہلے ہی گیند پارلیمان میں پھینک چکی ہے۔ کیونکہ اسے پتہ تھا کہ اگر پرویز مشرف کے آئین توڑنے کی بات چِھڑی تو وہ تین نومبر سنہ دو ہزار سات کے اقدامات تک نہیں رُکے گی بلکہ بات نکلے گی تو بارہ اکتوبر سنہ انیس سو ننانوے تک جائے گی

...

No trial, Saudis assure Musharraf

* Former president says he wants to put superior judiciary on trial
* Present govt still pursuing past regime’s policies with regard to US

Daily Times Monitor

LAHORE: Saudi King Abdullah bin Abdul Aziz has assured former president Pervez Musharraf that Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) chief Nawaz Sharif will not demand a treason trial for him under Article 6 of the constitution, a private TV channel reported on Sunday.

Musharraf told the channel he would demand that all the judges of the superior judiciary who had approved his steps also be tried for treason if the government charged him with sedition. He said the country’s national interest would have been compromised if he had not sided with the US in the war on terror after 9/11.

To a question, the former president said it was wrong to assume he had forced Dr Abdul Qadeer Khan to apologise for distributing nuclear secrets. He said Pakistan must fight and eradicate the Taliban and Al Qaeda.

Same policies: Musharraf said the present government was following the same strategic policies with regards to the US that his government had pursued, adding there were only minor differences in the modalities of official dealings. He said the military aid given to Pakistan for the war on terror had also been used to strengthen Pakistan’s defence against India. (Daily Times)

Nawaz Sharif calls on Saudi King Abdullah

LAHORE: PML-N chief Nawaz Sharif on Sunday met Saudi King Abdullah Bin Abdul Aziz in Makkah to discuss Pak-Saudi relations and issues facing Muslims around the world, a private TV channel reported. Sources said Saudi authorities had asked Nawaz to withdraw his demand for trying former president Pervez Musharraf under Article 6 of the constitution. Also, Gulf Times claimed that Nawaz was not given the highest level of protocol, which implied that the Saudis were not happy with him. daily times monitor/app

Read more...